Death Threats, Viral Hate, & A YouTube Paycheck: What Happens When You Disrupt Your Own Identity

A single, off-the-cuff YouTube video can change your life, but not always in the way you expect. We tell the true story of a nutrition creator who pivoted from a vegan, plant-based identity to a paleo message and watched the internet react in real time. What started as a simple attempt to answer repeated questions turned into overnight virality, intense backlash, and a hard lesson about what it costs to evolve in public.

We get honest about the messy middle of a personal brand pivot: building a platform slowly through Instagram, email marketing, and YouTube content strategy, then suddenly dealing with a flood of comments, emails, and harassment when the algorithm decides to amplify you. We also talk about creator mental health and online safety, including why boundaries like blocking, disabling comments, and stepping away from social media are not weakness, they are self-preservation. If you have ever feared posting your real opinion, switching niches, or telling a story that breaks your old identity, you will recognize the emotional whiplash.

Then we zoom out to the surprising business takeaway. Disruption can be brutal, but it can also be clarifying: the right audience starts to arrive, your message gets sharper, and your work can grow financially when you stop performing who you used to be. We unpack the idea that a little healthy pushback is sometimes a sign you are finally speaking with conviction, and that losing the wrong followers can create space for ideal clients and students.

Subscribe for more real conversations about identity shifts, authenticity, and building a sustainable business online, and if this hit home, share it with a friend and leave a review. What part of your old identity are you ready to let go of?

Connect with me on Instagram!  

Check out my website here.

Transcript

Identity Shifts Create Disruption

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Often when we step into this next identity and have this evolution of self, it comes with some disruption. And I was talking with one of my clients last night about this disruption that I noticed within my business within my nutrition business, um, maybe 12 years ago, it's definitely over a decade ago. But I wanted to share this story with you because now it's very funny to me. But at the time it felt like I would either sink or swim.

Building A Nutrition Platform Online

SPEAKER_00 0:34

So back in the day when I was practicing as a nutritionist and um was really out there kind of in the online space. I was growing my Instagram platform and I was also um building my email list and I was making YouTube videos, and those were all kind of avenues that I used for growth. And so YouTube was one of those things that it's a very time-consuming platform to grow. And it takes a lot to get monetized. Um, at the time, I was not monetized, but I had a couple-year plan to make that happen. I think I had just under a thousand subscribers on YouTube. And what the standards were at the time was that you had to have at least a thousand subscribers and something like 3,000 watched hours per month or something along those lines. I don't know what it looks like anymore, but there were these certain metrics that you had to meet in order to get paid from Google Ads. So, anyways, I had when I first when I was first a nutritionist, I was in nutrition school, and I was a vegan and a vegetarian, and I kind of lived in that ethos for several years, like so many of us have, I'm sure. We've all kind of dabbled in these different quote unquote diets and lifestyles. So when I was building, I was kind of known as being vegan and had predominantly plant-based content. And I actually raised my son the first year of his life, my eldest, um, as a vegan baby. And this is not to get into what is right or wrong, but the point of the story is that I was more or less known as that thing, that nutritionist that had a one-year-old baby that was thriving as a vegan, air quotes, thrive. Um, but what happened was people kept asking me, why did you stop being vegetarian? Why did you end your vegan journey? Why are you doing paleo now? And I was really, really big into paleo and it really transformed my health and our family's health and everything like that as a protocol.

Going Viral And Getting Targeted

SPEAKER_00 2:48

And so I decided one day that I had 30 minutes before I had to go pick up my kids from school. Um, the lighting was looking good in my living room. I was drinking an iced coffee and I was like, you know what? Screw it. I'm gonna sit down and I'm gonna answer these burning questions that people have had for the couple of years now about why I stopped being vegan. So I put that video up. I barely edited, edited it. That's a tongue twister, and kind of just threw it together. It was the most impromptu, just talk to camera kind of video. And I posted it and kind of just like walked away. And, you know, my videos on average would be like 500 to a thousand views was good for me. So I said it and forget it. And then I come back basically 24, 48 hours later, and that freaking video has gone viral. And I don't know, I don't mean this in any offensive way if this is your choice of diet or lifestyle, but there is nothing more terrifying on the face of the planet than angry vegans. And they came for me. That video had been shared on multiple different vegan websites, multiple different vegan platforms and threads to the point that I couldn't even comprehend or keep up with the comments and the emails that I was getting. And so it was quite jarring. It was like that overnight, unanticipated attention on your platform and on you as a person. And lo and behold, I'm obviously getting a ton of hate, a ton of hate. I'm getting death threats. I am getting threats to my family. I'm being told that my children should be taken away, that I'm a child murderer. Like the absolute scum of the internet came out and decided to put me on the last. And I ended up going into a bit of, I guess it was self-preservation, but I shut down that email account that was associated. I was like, I cannot see any more of these emails. They were just insane, unhinged. And I had disabled the comments. Um, this went on for a bit. And then I eventually went off of social media for, I think I was off for about six months. I could not handle it. My mental health was at an all-time low. And I was worried for the safety of myself and my children. I had two young children and I just didn't know what these people were capable of. And the things that they were saying were very descriptive, very graphic, and just honestly, in hindsight, if this had happened to me today, I would have taken it to the police. It was that bad.

Protecting Mental Health And Safety

SPEAKER_00 5:36

So, anyways, now coming out of this 10 plus years later, I realized that what I had done was disrupt what was normal for me. The identity that people had known me for came with a shift that I had to make for myself, for my family. And choosing, this was this is all a choice, right? Like when we put ourselves out on a public platform, it that is our choosing and that is our free will. And even though I don't ever believe that people should ever speak to other human beings the way that I was spoken to, you do have to come to the table assuming that you're gonna get a little bit of pushback. This was extreme. This was the next, this was next level. So it didn't never in a million years could I have expected that kind of reaction. But what happened was I also attracted a whole bunch of paleo people. And the paleo people were kind of coming in and really kind of like verifying my story. And that's what I was sharing. That's what's so crazy about it is that it wasn't me shaming anything or anyone. It was just me sharing my story. But that identity piece of me had to die the most brutal death in order for that next elevation. And the reason that I'm sharing this is because I can see just how much of an evolution that led for me. Because of all those angry vegans coming at me and sharing my video all over the interwebs, I got monetized. I was making a good chunk of change off of YouTube every single month. It also attracted more of my people to me. Don't get me wrong, I went on a blocking spree. I don't think I've ever blocked more people in my entire life than I did within that month period. I also then had some growth in my business as a result of putting myself out there and sharing my story and being so vulnerable and just subject to whatever the internet was willing to throw at me. And so now I look back at that and I'm like, that was freaking wild. And I don't wish that on anybody. Like, that's that's dangerous territory, and you have to be very mindful of how the internet affects you and you need to make choices in that moment.

Why Pushback Can Signal Alignment

SPEAKER_00 7:54

But this is the identity piece. This is the disruption. I disrupted a niche, I disrupted something that was no longer me and said, this is who I am now, and here's my story. And so that led to that evolution of a completely different demographic of people following me, a pretty substantial boom in my business financially and in terms of growth. And so this is kind of that identity shift that I want you to be not prepared for. You should never be prepared for what I endured. But just knowing that when you move into this new identity, when you start using your voice in a strong way and saying, this is what I do, this is who I am, it's not uncommon for there to be pushback. And I actually think that when you're getting a little bit of healthy pushback or a little bit of positive criticism, it means that you're doing something right. It means that you're activating slash triggering. I don't see a difference between the two. They're the exact same visceral reaction that happens to people and the action that happens after somebody gets triggered or activated can often look the same. But you are gonna do that. You are gonna do that to people. And that is okay because for everybody that, you know, you you schloth off, you are making way and making room and space energetically

Choosing Your Voice And Your People

SPEAKER_00 9:20

for more of your people to come into your world. There is always somebody that is going to love you and be your ideal student or your ideal client because of your authenticity and your bravery and standing in your convictions. So if you're finding that as you switch niches or as you hone in on a message or you niche down even further, you are disrupting some people, that is okay. That's usually a good indicator that you are on the right path.